About Scott Sheftall

Experience. Integrity. Results.

scott_ap_1.original-gigapixel-low resolution v2-4x-faceai v2

Experienced Mediator and Board-Certified Civil Trial Lawyer in Florida

With over 47 years of legal experience, Scott D. Sheftall is a Florida Bar Board-Certified Civil Trial Lawyer and a Florida Supreme Court Certified Civil Circuit Court Mediator. Throughout his career, he has led over 100 high-profile cases across more than 30 practice areas, including personal injury, medical malpractice, business disputes, and maritime law, securing multi-million-dollar verdicts and settlements. His extensive experience in the courtroom has provided him with the ability to guide parties toward fair and effective solutions through mediation.

Scott is committed to providing clients with an efficient and peaceful alternative to litigation. He offers mediation services throughout Florida, virtually, on-site at a preferred location, or at his office in downtown Jacksonville. By leveraging his legal expertise and impartial approach, Scott helps parties resolve disputes with respect, clarity, and a focus on mutually beneficial outcomes. From handling complex commercial disputes to personal injury claims, Scott provides a trusted way to reach a resolution outside of the courtroom.

Bar Admissions

  • Florida, 1977
  • U.S. Court of Appeals 11th Circuit, 1983
  • U.S. District Court Southern District of Florida, 1977
  • U.S. District Court Middle District of Florida, 1983
  • U.S. Supreme Court, 1982

Education

  • University of Florida College of Law, Gainesville, Florida – J.D. – 1976
  • Davidson College, Davidson, North Carolina – B.A. – 1973
  • Trinity College, University of Cambridge – 1975 – International Trade Law

Explore the Benefits of Mediation

An Alternative to Litigation

Mediation offers an alternative to the time, cost, and uncertainty of traditional courtroom battles, allowing parties to resolve disputes more efficiently.

Neutral and Impartial Process

As a trained mediator, Scott Sheftall facilitates the process, ensuring that all parties are heard and treated fairly, with no bias or predetermined outcomes.

Confidential and Private

Unlike court cases, mediation is a private process where discussions and settlements remain confidential, offering parties a safe space to negotiate.

Flexible and Convenient

Mediation can be scheduled at a convenient time and place, whether in-person or virtually, offering flexibility and convenience in finding a resolution.

Empowerment to Control the Outcome

Unlike a judge or jury, the parties in mediation have the power to craft their own resolution, ensuring that the outcome aligns with their needs.

Cost-Effective and Time-Saving

Mediation is generally quicker and more affordable than going through a full trial, helping to reduce legal fees and minimize delays in resolving the issue.

Why Choose Scott Sheftall?

Choosing the right mediator can make all the difference in resolving a conflict. With over 47 years of experience, Scott is not just trained in mediation—he’s spent decades practicing high-level litigation, handling complex cases across a wide range of legal areas. His blend of practical experience and compassionate, unbiased guidance ensures that your mediation will be handled with professionalism and care, leading to a resolution that works for all parties involved.

Credentials and Expertise:
  • Florida Bar Board Certified Civil Trial Lawyer since 1988
  • Fellow, American Board of Trial Advocates
  • Fellow, International Society of Barristers
  • Recognized as a “Super Lawyer” every year since 2006
  • 2025 Martindale-Hubbell “AV Preeminent” Attorney
  • Named one of the “Top Attorneys in South Florida” by South Florida Legal Guide
  • Named one of “Northeast Florida’s Top Attorneys”
 

With a proven track record and a respected reputation in the legal field, Scott is dedicated to guiding you toward a fair and lasting resolution of your dispute.

The Legal Execution Department makes an appointment with the customer to sign a mediation agreement
IMG_1082-Lynda-Weeden-scaled

Find a Resolution that Works For You

With decades of experience, Scott offers a neutral and client-centered approach to mediation, ensuring that all parties are heard and respected. Start the process today and take the first step toward a fair, lasting solution. Schedule your mediation now to get started.